Previous by Date | Next by Date | Date Index
Previous by Thread | Next by Thread
| Thread Index
| LM_NET
Archive
| |
TFTD has received several messages concerning today's TFTD. Here is the one with the most explanation. I hope the explanation is valid. tftd regrets the error. -tftd (The URLs just came in. tftd has not read them yet.) here's the orginal column: http://www.chicago.tribune.com/news/current/schmich0601.htm and here's the follow-up, if you look today: http://www.chicago.tribune.com/news/current/schmich.htm From: sandor weisz <ferris@merle.acns.nwu.edu> From: "rebecca l. eisenberg" <mars@bossanova.com> Subject: yet another fraud >From: Neil Rest <NeilRest@tezcat.com> >Subject: hoax retraction [BURNED!!] > >>A fast note to let you know the Vonnegut commencement address is a >>phony. >>A good phony, but a phony. And it's getting sprayed all across the >>net. >> >>Yes, I'm positive. >> >>Bob Weide, Vonnegut's friend and the author & co-producer of the >>movie >>rendition of "Mother Night", wrote: > >>:Yesterday I confirmed for the Vonnegut Newsgroup that the MIT >>address >>:attributed to Kurt, and spread all over the Web, was a hoax. It >>was not >>:written nor delivered by Kurt at MIT or anywhere. Copies of this >>thing were >>:E-mailed to me from all corners -- even received one from Scotland. >>: >>:Well, it seems as though my response spread through the Internet >>almost as >>:thoroughly as the speech itself. Today (8/1), my E-mailbox was >>full of >>:letters from strangers, responding to my post. In any event, I can >>now >>:clear up part of this mystery: >>: >>:There is a columnist for the Chicago Tribune named Mary Schmich. >>The words >>:were hers, in her column from the June 1 issue of the Trib. She >>never >>:passed it off as Vonnegut s, nor was his name ever evoked in the >>column. In >>:fact, her column contained a prologue, missing on the Internet >>version, >>:which I will reprint here... >>: >>:********************************************************************* >>******* >>: >>:ADVICE, LIKE YOUTH, PROBABLY JUST WASTED ON THE YOUNG >>: >>:"Inside every adult lurks a graduation speaker dying to get out, >>some >>:world-weary pundit eager to pontificate on life to young people >>who'd >>:rather be Rollerblading. Most of us, alas, will never be invited >>to sow >>:our words of wisdom among an audience of caps and gowns, but >>there's no >>:reason we can't entertain ourselves by composing a Guide to Life for >>:Graduates. >>: >>:"I encourage anyone over 26 to try this and thank you for >>indulging my >>:attempt. >>: >>:"Ladies and gentlemen of the Class of 97..." >>: >>:********************************************************************* >>***** >>: >>:The missing piece of this puzzle is: Who is "Culprit Zero?" That >>is, who >>:originally placed it on the Internet, crediting it to Kurt? Mary >>Schmich, >>:whom I spoke with today (a very nice woman, by the way), was >>horrified at >>:the idea that anyone would think the deed was hers, or that she >>was trying >>:to "rip Kurt off." She told me she had read "Cat's Cradle" back in >>college, >>:but that was about it. She's never heard him speak and couldn't >>consciously >>:duplicate his style if she wanted to. She even tracked Kurt down >>on the >>:phone today to explain what had happened and confirm her lack of >>:culpability. Kurt was, of course, good natured about it. (Frankly, >>my fear >>:is that this will be the new "Venus on the Halfshell" and that >>Kurt will be >>:hounded over the next few years by people asking him about his MIT >>address.) >>: >>:One last point: Mary said that when her article originally >>appeared in the >>:Tribune, she certainly received a favorable reaction and some nice >>phone >>:calls, but that was all. Suddenly, the same words are credited to a >>:well-known author, and it's being quoted and E-mailed all over the >>world >>:within hours. Talk about the power of name recognition. Also, >>another >>:lesson in individual responsibility, or lack thereof, in the >>computer age. >>: >>:I beleive Mary is now working on a column about all this for the >>weekend >>:Tribune. Pat Bartoshesky Saint Edmond's Academy (Gr.4-8, boys only) Librarian 2120 Veale Rd. Wilmington DE 19810-4199 <pbarto@udel.edu> VOICE: 302-4765-5370 FAX: 302-475-2256 =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= To quit LM_NET (or set NOMAIL or DIGEST), Send an email message to: listserv@listserv.syr.edu In the message write either: 1) SIGNOFF LM_NET or 2) SET LM_NET NOMAIL or 3) SET LM_NET DIGEST For more help see LM_NET On The Web: http://ericir.syr.edu/lm_net/ =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=