LM_NET: Library Media Networking

Previous by DateNext by Date Date Index
Previous by ThreadNext by Thread Thread Index
LM_NET Archive



I want to thank everyone for their responses.  I believe you all saved my
career, sanity, and life.  WHAT WAS I THINKING?????  My original post asked
whether I should invest in a few classroom sets of paperback novels for the
teachers in my school district (I am the YA librarian at a public library). I
received quite a mixed bag of opinion (most negative), but read for yourself.

By the way,
I have decided to NOT go forward with this due to:
1. the fear of investing a lot of $$ and having the titles challenged by
parents.
2. the local school board may just decide that they no longer need to fund
this if I       am.
3. If I do this for the public school, I will have to do it for all 10
private schools, as well as the three Cleveland private schools just over the
border where many Euclidians send their kids.  Also, do teachers who live in
Euclid but teach elsewhere get access to the sets?

I believe that I will try another tactic (manipulative, evil and devious
creature that I am).  The Clevnet system will not send me 30 copies of a
single title on the teacher's card.
BUT, what if I have the teacher compile a list of the students' names &
library card numbers?  She can call me with the title she wants, and I can
find out if the required number of copies are available.  If there are
enough, she can come in with the list and I can place a unique hold for each
kid.  If the system is a few short, I can order a few to make up the
difference.  How about it?  Do you think it might work??

*****Anyway, The Hit starts here******

It is the district's responsibility to purchase textbooks -- and multi-copies
of curriculum materials (like novels) come under that heading. My predecessor
spent more of her library budget on perhaps four or five classrooms than in
her four libraries that she administered.

When I assumed the position the principals came to me wanting the library to
purchase classroom sets of dictionaries, encyclopedias, novels, almanacs and
even atlases!

Would you purchase instructional videos for the school?

You are obviously a nice, kind hearted person. As a former public library
board member, a few school districts asked our regional library to take over
the school libraries. (They wanted the public library to move into the school
so they would not have to pay the librarian's salary, provide a materials
budget, etc.).

*************
Our classroom teachers would love us to buy the books, unfortunately
that would cut deeply into our book budget.  Their department has funds
for the books.  I'm afraid that if the library starts providing class
sets of reading material, next we'll be asked to purchase textbooks --
something I don't want to do  (the loss of time and money would be too
great).

************
I think our teachers would love it and definitely use them!

***********
as school librarian, have bought and do buy classroom sets for the teachers
at  my school.  In other elelmentary schools in the system, classroom
teachers were given budget money with which to purchase sets.  Why not your
school system's money?

**********
I have library classroom sets (35) of PBs.  In fact, tomorrow I will go
to the Scholastic Warehouse and spend part of the vouchers on this also.

I am working closely with my teachers on what books do they want to have
as classroom sets.  We have ordered s complete set of guided reading
books for the K-2 areas.  We have about 30 sets for the 3-5 areas.  I
have also complete classroom sets of the supporting science pbs for our
science adoption.

My teachers want about another 15 sets of books.  I have copies of these
books also on the shelves.  Each book is barcoded for tracking of where
it is.

I have these sets in a special area.  Whenever I purchase Battle of the
Books sets I keep in mind which titles to purchase so that I can add to
the sets.

**************
I'm not a teacher (as you can see), but your idea sounds GREAT to me!

I'll bet a lot of LM_NET people would like to read your responses!!

Sounds like a good way of working together with the schools!!

**************
Dawn, I'm not at a Public Library, but I do carry 30 copies of 10 different
titles as requested by my teachers.  The students just come in to check them
out for an extended check out period.  Just like they would textbooks.  Some
of the schools in my county do buy novels sets with their textbook monies.
I just happen to have both the LMC and textbooks under my charge.

The only problem I see is that if the teachers check the books out and the
students are neglectful (who them?) and fold, spindle, or mutilate...not to
mention lose those books then the teacher would be responsible.

*****************
Teachers should not have to purchase sets of books but it should not be the
role of the public library to provide educational material to the school.  I
can imagine how the Cleveland Public Library balked at sending that many
books to the school.  I feel your role is to support the local curriculum
and your patrons but not to supply the materials they should be responsible
for.

*****************
Concerns: How would you decide what titles to buy? How many grade levels
would you purchase for? How to you ensure that the books are getting to all
of the people who would like to use them? How do you make sure that teachers
new to a district know they are available? How do you ensure that the
materials are approved by local school boards so that a school challenge
doesn't become your own?

As far as the advantages: My teeny tiny budget can't accomodate classroom
sets and accreditation teams wouldn't count the titles as titles in my
library (beyond 5). It encourages teacher use of the public library and
hopefully would also promote collaboration between you both. Have you
considered broaching the topic with your local librarians?

**********
As a teacher-librarian and a classroom teacher, I don't think the
public library should be providing classroom novel sets - I'd prefer to have
you come to school and booktalk anytime - I'd prefer teachers not to use
classroom sets of novels (how about meeting the students' needs and
interests in literature circles instead?) - I'd prefer you to spend the
money on items that will support the curriculum rather than items that ARE
the curriculum - I really value the cooperation between our public
librarians and the schools - I don't want the school board to have more
excuses to cut back school library budgets.  Thanks for the thought, though.

**********
I feel that if it's related to curriculum, teachers should have to pay
for this.  I don't feel that I should purchase class sets for our
teachers (I'm in a school).  I feel that we need to have a variety of
books, not just megaglops of one title.

*********
Do not do this.  If you do it for a couple teachers then all the teachers in
your district will want the same.  Your children's department will also be
hit up to provide the service.  It happened to my public library here.  Also,
there were problems coordinating who got to use the books.  Teachers who live
in the district but teach in other districts also wanted access to the books.
 Books got ruined and were unavailable for the teachers who had specifically
requested the titles.  If you do this, you will regret it.  You will never be
forgiven for a kind act.

*********

Dawn Sardes
YA Librarian
Euclid Public Library
Euclid, OH
dmsardes@aol.com

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-==-=
All postings to LM_NET are protected under copyright law.
To quit LM_NET (or set-reset NOMAIL or DIGEST), send email to:
listserv@listserv.syr.edu   In the message write EITHER:
1) SIGNOFF LM_NET 2) SET LM_NET NOMAIL or 3) SET LM_NET DIGEST
4) SET LM_NET MAIL  * Please allow for confirmation from Listserv.
For LM_NET Help see: http://ericir.syr.edu/lm_net/
Archives: http://askeric.org/Virtual/Listserv_Archives/LM_NET.html
 See also EL-Announce for announcements from library media vendors:
    http://www.mindspring.com/~el-announce/
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=--=-=-=

LM_NET Mailing List Home